Johnny's
Italian Steakhouse - Middleton, WI
Dinner Menu
APPETIZERS
BETTA BRUSCHETTA Grilled focaccia bread topped with fresh Roma
tomatoes, chevre goat cheese, onions, olive oil and basil. It’s
the goat cheese that makes it betta! - 5.99 • Even
betta with shrimp - 7.99
CALAMARI MARINARA Lightly breaded
and fried. Served with marinara and Johnny’s dipping sauce
- 7.99
CLASSIC SHRIMP COCKTAIL Served with two great sauces:
tangy cocktail and Johnny’s dipping sauce - 8.99
FRESH
STEAMED MUSSELS Simmered in a white wine garlic or tomato
pesto sauce - 8.99
ITALIAN SAUSAGE STUFFED MUSHROOMS Overstuffed,
smothered with cheese and baked until bubbly - 6.99
GREAT CRAB CAKES Our winning recipe made with lots of real crabmeat. Sautéed
and served with rémoulade sauce -
8.99
ZUCCHINI
FRIES Crisp shoestring zucchini fries served with rémoulade
dipping sauce - 5.99
SAUSAGE BREAD Home baked bread stuffed
with sausage, onion, Mozzarella and Colby cheese. Served
with marinara sauce - 6.99
MOZZARELLA MARINARA Wedges of
lightly fried Mozzarella with fresh marinara and pesto sauce
- 5.99
VERY OWN ITALIAN SAUSAGE Grilled with peppers
and onions. Also makes a great side dish - 6.49
ROMA TOMATOES & FRESH
BUFFALO MOZZARELLA Topped with fresh basil, olive oil and balsamic
vinegar - 6.99
LITTLE ITALY
COMBINATION A “Grande” helping of all
Johnny’s favorites: Calamari Marinara, Sausage Bread, Mozzarella
Marinara and Shrimp Bruschetta - 12.99
HOMEMADE
SOUPS & SALADS
SUPPERCLUB SPINACH SALAD Served with
traditional hot bacon dressing topped with sun-dried tomatoes,
pecans, prosciutto and hard boiled egg - 8.99
Served as a side salad - 2.99
WARM GOAT CHEESE SALAD Pecan crusted goat
cheese with shredded green apple over a bed of leafy mesclun lettuce mix with
a sprinkling of blue cheese. Served with
a balsamic vinaigrette dressing - 8.99
PARMIGIANO CHICKEN SALAD Hand-breaded
Parmesan crusted chicken breast, red onion and Roma tomatoes set atop garden
greens tossed with tomato basil vinaigrette
- 9.99
TRADITIONAL CAESAR Crisp romaine,
creamy Caesar dressing, garlic croutons & Parmesan cheese
- 5.99 • With chicken - 8.99 • With
shrimp - 10.99
PEPPER SEARED SALMON SALAD Fresh Atlantic
salmon, balsamic greens, Parmesan, crostini, chevre goat cheese,
red onion and Roma tomatoes
- 9.99
MINESTRONE SOUP Lots of Johnny’s best ingredients
in here! Cup - 3.25 • Bowl - 3.99
BAKED POTATO SOUP
A classic favorite! Topped with bacon and cheese. Cup - 3.25 • Bowl
- 3.99
SEAFOOD
SPECIALTIES
PESCE BASILICO A fresh water snapper
fillet with fresh basil, garlic, tomatoes and a touch of olive
oil - 14.99
PESCE PICCATA A fresh water snapper fillet with
lemon, butter, white wine, capers and a touch of diced red onion
- 14.99
CRISPY DILLED FISH A crusted tilapia fillet topped
with shrimp and smothered in a creamy dill sauce reduction. Johnny’s
latest sensation! - 17.99
SEAFOOD SKEWERS Twin kabobs of shrimp,
scallops, whitefish, Atlantic salmon and fresh vegetables char-broiled
and basted with garlic,
basil pesto. Served with red pepper sauce, garlic pesto mayonnaise
and wild rice - 16.99
ATLANTIC SALMON Perfectly char-broiled
and served with a white wine butter sauce - 15.99
LOBSTER DINNER An 8 oz lobster tail
broiled to perfection - 26.99 • Add another 8 oz
lobster tail - 19.99
SALMON FIORINTINO Fresh Atlantic salmon
stuffed with chevre goat cheese, spinach and pine nuts then sesame
crusted, baked and
served with a white wine tarragon butter sauce and wild rice
- 16.99 - Our taste testers favorite
CEDAR PLANKED SALMON Fresh
Atlantic salmon roasted on a cedar plank and glazed with our
apricot butter - 15.99
CRAB STUFFED SHRIMP Tiger prawns
filled with our crab cake stuffing and baked with béarnaise sauce
- 16.99
STEAKS & CHOPS
Our bred-to-be-the-best premium steaks are hand selected and aged
21 days.
All Johnny’s steaks and seafood specialties are served with our family-style
house salad (substitute side Caesar salad for 99¢ or side Spinach salad
for 1.99), fresh baked bread and a choice of garlic roasted mashed potatoes,
steamed broccoli, pasta marinara, wild rice or baked potato (loaded - add 99¢).
Add an 8 oz Lobster Tail - 19.99 · Add a Skewer of Grilled Shrimp
- 5.99
HALF POUND BLACK ANGUS BURGERS AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST
STEAK DEBURGO Our signature steak Medallions
of beef tenderloin sautéed with roasted garlic, fresh
thyme, basil and oregano and laced with a cream sauce. Served
with roasted garlic mashed potatoes - 22.99
FILET MEDALLION
TRIO We prepare three individual filets, char-broiled to order
and top them with horseradish, Iowa Maytag blue cheese and Parmesan crusts. Served
with roasted garlic mashed potatoes and a rich demi-glaze - 22.99
CHUBBY
CUT TOP SIRLOIN Cut from the heart of the sirloin, a center-cut steak weighing
in at a chubby 10 oz - 15.99 • 14 oz - 18.99
CHAR-BROILED RIBEYE Trimmed to the Delmonico cut (no tail) 10 oz - 17.99 • 16
oz - 20.99
STUFFED PORK CHOPS Pork chops stuffed with sun-dried tomatoes,
Prosciutto ham and Polenta. Char-broiled and served with garlic roasted
mashed potatoes and Marsala wine sauce. One chop - 13.99 • Two chops
- 16.99
OUR HOUSE PORK CHOPS Char-broiled and topped with a Cabernet
demi-glaze. One chop - 12.99 • Two chops - 15.99
PARMESAN
CRUSTED NEW YORK STRIP A gentleman’s cut at 12 oz char-broiled
and finished with a Parmesan butter crust. A house specialty - 21.99
PORTERHOUSE
STEAK We offer you a 24 oz - that’s right 24 ounces of Choice
beef for the
real meat lover in you - 25.99
STEAK TOPPERS
Homemade butter crusts. Select
from Horseradish, Iowa Maytag blue cheese or Parmesan - 1.99 • Mushrooms
- 1.99 • Grilled Onions - 50¢ • Top
any steak Oscar Style with crabmeat, fresh asparagus and
béarnaise sauce - 4.99
DRUNKEN STEAK Marinated in pale ale
and special herbs. Served on top of our garlic cream sauce -
17.99 The owner’s recommendation
CRUSTED STEAK AND
SHRIMP Our Parmesan-crusted 7 oz top sirloin
cooked to order with three of our crab cake stuffed shrimp - 21.99 Substitute
6 oz filet for the 7 oz top sirloin - add 4.99
MIDWEST’S
BEST FILET MIGNON Cut from the center of the tenderloin • 6oz
petite - 17.99 • 9oz large cut - 22.99
FILET
OSCAR Our best filet with crab cake stuffing, char-broiled and
topped with fresh asparagus and béarnaise sauce
- 21.99
VEAL PARMIGIANO We sauté slices of Provimi
veal, top it with marinara sauce and Mozzarella cheese and bake
it until bubbly
- 16.99
VEAL PICCATA Slices of Provimi veal sautéed
and finished with lemon, butter, white wine and capers - 16.99
VEAL
MARSALA Provimi veal sautéed with red onion, mushrooms,
Marsala wine and finished with fresh cream - 16.99
VEAL
SINATRA This will turn your eyes blue. Slices of Provimi veal
sautéed with chunks of shrimp, snow crab, a variety of
mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh basil and roasted garlic
simmered in
a light cream sauce - 19.99
OVEN-ROASTED PRIME RIB (Available
Friday, Saturday and Sunday) We slow roast for a minimum of eight
hours to bring out the extra
flavor - 8 oz 16.99 • 12 oz 19.99 • 16 oz 21.99 Prime
rib can be blackened Cajun style at no extra charge
SOON TO BE FAMOUS IRON SKILLET POTATOES
Rich creamy shredded
potatoes seared in iron skillets until crispy on the outside,
served loaded with Wisconsin Cheddar cheese. Perfect as an appetizer or as
a side dish. Enough for two or more - 5.99
FAVORITES,
PASTA & CHICKEN
Served with our family-style house salad bowl and fresh baked bread.
Substitute side Caesar salad for 99¢ or side Spinach salad
for 1.99
CHICKEN OR SHRIMP MINELLI Johnny’s homemade garlic cream
sauce and fettuccine tossed with grilled chicken breast - 11.99 • With
shrimp - 13.99 • Add mushrooms and bacon for
1.99
EGGPLANT PARMIGIANO Breaded medallions of eggplant topped
with Mozzarella and Parmesan cheese and Johnny’s marinara
sauce. Served with a side of pasta marinara -12.99
SCAMPI
ANGELLINI Shrimp sautéed in olive oil, garlic,
spinach, tomatoes, button mushrooms, lemon and white wine.
Tossed with angel
hair pasta and fresh Parmesan cheese - 15.99
TORTELLINI
PORTABELLA Sautéed portabella mushrooms and fresh
vegetables in a Parmesan cream sauce with cheese tortellini
- 10.99 • With chicken - 13.49 • With
shrimp - 15.49
ANGEL HAIR Angel hair pasta, served either Basilico
style with fresh basil, garlic and tomatoes or in a Traditional
butter garlic sauce - 8.99 • With chicken
- 11.99 • With shrimp - 13.99
CLASSIC SPAGHETTI We worked hard to make the best spaghetti marinara that would
even make Mama proud - 9.99 • With
meat sauce - 10.99 • With Johnny’s very own Italian
sausage - 11.99
SEAFOOD PASTA POMODORO A generous portion
of Mediterranean seafood including shrimp, mussels and scallops
tossed with
roma tomatoes, garlic,
spinach and Portabella mushrooms in an olive oil and aromatic
broth over linguine - 15.99
CHICKEN PICCATA Chicken
breast sautéed and finished
with lemon, butter, white wine, capers and a touch of diced
red onion. Served with choice of fresh vegetables, pasta
marinara or
garlic mashed potatoes - 12.99
CHICKEN PARMIGIANO Parmesan breaded
chicken breast smothered in marinara, topped with Mozzarella
and baked until bubbly. Served with choice of pasta marinara
or garlic mashed potatoes - 13.99
ROSEMARY CHICKEN PORTABELLA Pan-seared chicken breast with portabella mushrooms in rosemary
Marsala sauce topped with Provolone and served
with roasted garlic mashed potatoes - 13.99
CHANEL NO. 5 Marilyn’s
trademark! We took her five favorites - lobster, shrimp, artichokes, prosciutto
and cheese ravioli - added our homemade garlic cream sauce and
came up with this movie
star bombshell - 17.99
CHEF ANDY’S HOMESTYLE RIGATONI Spicy Italian sausage with portabella mushrooms tossed with rigatoni
pasta in a spicy tomato
cream sauce - 12.99
LASAGNA WITH MEAT SAUCE Layered pasta
with seasoned Ricotta cheese with a plum tomato and meat sauce,
topped with lots of Mozzarella
- 11.99
SALMON, SPINACH AND ARTICHOKE PASTA Served
in a light garlic cream sauce. Topped with Mozzarella cheese
and baked to perfection
- 12.99
HEART OF ITALY COMBINATION A combination of Chicken Parmigiano,
fettuccini with Johnny’s homemade garlic cream sauce and
Parmesan crusted 7 oz. top sirloin char-broiled to your liking
- 18.99 • Substitute 6 oz filet for the
7 oz top sirloin - add 4.99
CHICKEN MARSALA Breast of chicken
sautéed with red onion,
mushrooms, Marsala wine and finished with fresh cream. Served
with your choice of pasta marinara or garlic mashed potatoes
- 13.99
DESSERTS
JOHNNY’S WARM CHOCOLATE CAKE Fresh baked chocolate cake served with a molten center and
cinnamon ice cream.
CREME BRULEE Sweet cream, egg yolks,
vanilla and sugar baked into a smooth custard, caramelized with
sugar.
CANNOLI Twin crisp cannoli shells stuffed with mascarpone
and chocolate mousse.
FRESH BERRY CHEESECAKE A fresh strawberry
and blueberry cheesecake on a graham cracker crust with fresh
whipped cream.
JOHNNY’S TIRAMISU CAKE Layers
of ladyfingers dipped in coffee and rum, Mascarpone cheese blended
with amaretto, espresso and sweetened with fresh whipped
cream. All on top of a chocolate ganache pie crust finished with
a dusting of cocoa. A Johnny’s favorite!
TURTLE CHEESECAKE We take our white chocolate cheesecake and top it with chocolate
ganache frosting, creamy caramel and chopped pecans.
GRAND
MARNIER CHOCOLATE MOUSSE Rich imported dark chocolate mixed
with heavy
cream and Grand Marnier laced with real whipped cream.
Thoroughly
cooking foods of animal origin such as beef, eggs, fish, lamb
poultry or shellfish
reduces the risk of food-borne illness.
Individuals with certain health conditions may be at higher risk
if these foods are consumed raw or undercooked.
COFFEE
DRINKS
ITALIAN COFFEE Bailey’s, amaretto,
coffee and whipped cream
CAFÉ VERONIQUE Peppermint
Schnapps, Crème de Cocoa, coffee and
whipped cream
CAFÉ ALPINE Baileys, coffee
and whipped cream
CAFÉ FRANCESCO Tia Maria, Grand
Marnier, Crème de Cocoa, coffee
and whipped cream